Seeing What Isn’t There: Apophenia and the Art (and Science) of Physiotherapy
By: Maggie Bergeron, MSc(PT) ∙ Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

Seeing What Isn’t There: Apophenia and the Art (and Science) of Physiotherapy

Have you ever had a patient tell you that a certain stretch “always makes their shoulder worse”, or that their back pain “definitely started right after that one rainy day”?

As physiotherapists, we hear stories like this all the time. These narratives are often sincere, deeply felt, and sometimes wildly inaccurate from a clinical perspective.

Welcome to the fascinating world of Apophenia, the brain’s remarkable (and occasionally misleading) ability to find patterns, even when none actually exist.

What Is Apophenia?

Coined by German neurologist Klaus Conrad, Apophenia describes our tendency to perceive connections and meaning between unrelated things. It’s why we see shapes in clouds, faces in power outlets, or feel like a certain ritual “guarantees” a good workout. It's a survival trait—an evolutionary mechanism that helped our ancestors avoid threats by recognizing patterns in chaos.

But while this pattern-spotting is usually helpful, it can misfire.

How Does This Relate to Physiotherapy?

In physiotherapy, both clinicians and patients are vulnerable to apophenic thinking—especially when dealing with chronic pain, complex movement disorders, or subjective symptoms that don’t fit neatly into a biomechanical box.

Let’s look at a few examples.

Patient Narratives: Correlation vs. Causation

“Every time I sit on a soft couch, my sciatica flares up.”

This might be true… or it might be coincidence. The brain, craving certainty, quickly links cause and effect, even with limited evidence.

As clinicians, it’s our job to listen empathetically, but also help patients distinguish between correlation and causation. Otherwise, they may avoid activities unnecessarily or develop fear-based movement patterns.

Therapist Bias: The Treatment Worked—Or Did It?

“Myofascial release worked wonders for that patient’s hip pain!”

It might have… or the improvement could be due to natural recovery, the therapeutic alliance, or even the placebo effect. Apophenia affects therapists too. We may see positive outcomes and attribute them to a specific intervention, reinforcing our bias, even if objective evidence is lacking.

Evidence-based practice helps guard against this, but the human brain doesn’t easily give up its patterns.

Over-Attribution of Meaning to Test Results

“The patient has an anterior pelvic tilt—no wonder they have knee pain.”

We love connecting dots. But over-interpreting biomechanical findings can lead to over-treatment or overly complex explanations that confuse patients rather than empower them. Not every “abnormal” alignment is clinically relevant.

Superstitions in Rehab

“If I skip this stretch, I’ll definitely get injured again.”

This is classic apophenia: a pattern based on past experience, reinforced by fear. While routine can be helpful, rituals based on flawed assumptions can limit progress and create dependence on unnecessary interventions.

Turning Apophenia into a Therapeutic Tool

Here’s the twist: while apophenia can mislead, it can also be harnessed for good.

Humans are wired to seek meaning. In physiotherapy, we can:

• Use narrative to help patients understand their condition in ways that feel coherent.

• Guide pattern recognition toward helpful habits (e.g., “Notice how your pain improves after walking”).

• Reframe unhelpful beliefs by gently challenging inaccurate patterns they've formed.

• Leverage placebo and expectation—patients who believe in a treatment often experience better outcomes.
  
  

And perhaps most practically...

Use Streaks to Encourage Adherence

You’ve probably heard about streaks in apps like Duolingo, where users earn a flame icon for every day they complete a lesson. Miss a day? The flame resets.

That’s not just a fun gimmick—it’s a strategic use of apophenia. The brain sees the streak as meaningful progress, even though each day is statistically independent. Just like a gambler convinced they’re “on a roll,” people don’t want to break the streak.

In physiotherapy, we can ethically leverage this same principle to boost adherence — and digital tools like Embodia make this practical, visible, and trackable. On Embodia’s daily dashboard, patients see exactly what exercises are scheduled for that day, can mark them as complete, log sets and reps, and even note symptom levels or add personal diary comments. 

This digital daily check‑in creates a built‑in streak of engagement:

• Visual completion markers: When a patient marks an exercise “done,” it reinforces a sense of accomplishment and continuity from one day to the next. 

• Push reminders: Optional reminders encourage consistency by bringing the behavior into the patient’s daily rhythm. 

• Progress diary: Patients can record notes on performance or symptoms, giving them and their therapist a narrative of progress over time. 

These features don’t just record what was done — they help patients see the pattern of their effort, which makes them more likely to maintain it. When the brain perceives a continuous chain of completed days, it reinforces the behavior and increases the odds that patients will stick with their programs (even on days pain or motivation wane).

By using Embodia in this way, clinicians can turn the brain’s pattern‑seeking tendencies into ethical, evidence‑aligned motivation — keeping patients engaged and helping them build movement habits that feel meaningful and achievable.

Final Thoughts: Pattern Recognition with Caution

Pattern recognition is one of your most powerful clinical tools. But it needs guardrails.

In a profession that balances science with the art of healing, recognizing apophenia—both in ourselves and our patients—can lead to better reasoning, clearer communication, and more ethical care.

By understanding how our brains crave patterns, we can better support behavior change, improve patient outcomes, and keep rehab engaging—not just effective.

Because in the end, it’s not just about correcting posture or strengthening muscles. It’s about helping people create new, healthier patterns—both in their bodies and their minds.

---
Date written: 30 Dec 2025
Last update: 30 Dec 2025